F&O trading should be banned

annual reminder for saving my brothers from monetary wreck.

Yeah seen this few occasions now. He appears to get indignant periodically (information?), however we can not do something about it so he comes right here.

I do assume some type of preliminary brakes should be there with leverage, as a result of individuals are silly with cash. By some means, it ought to be higher drilled into individuals that there’s threat on this and you may lose all cash and extra and most of the people lose.If after that somebody gambles, its his mistake alone. Identical factor can occur in investing and in different kinds too. A idiot and his cash …

Past that, i believe i wrote this earlier than as properly – buying and selling improves market effectivity and value discovery. If issues are badly priced, traders will endure too, solely have to see how we will have issues with debt funds holding illiquid stuff in occasions of stress.

And never every thing has to have some worth for you particularly. For me, non secular constructions and financial system have zero worth, astrologers have zero worth, AYUSH has zero worth and even destructive and many others and many others and many others. Totally different individuals can have totally different values for some issues, you don’t cease simply since you don’t prefer it.

No real interest in arguing additional.

The reply is straightforward simply give an examination if you wish to commerce f&o. This eliminates the individuals who lose cash with out understanding the derivatives product. So now whoever loses cash actually misplaced due to dangerous evaluation dangerous timing or no matter.

Your submit doesn’t make sense simply because some fool misplaced cash ban derivatives all collectively. There are individuals who get into large debt and by no means pay again. Ought to we cease loans as properly? Derivatives buying and selling must exist, it helps to hedge positions within the fairness market however then you definately’ll say bare derivatives must be banned to which i’ll disagree once more. See we’d like people who find themselves prepared to take that threat of bare positions to earn income. These individuals create liquidity and higher market effeciency. However I do help that retailers ought to be in some way made conscious of what they’re actually buying and selling in and the way totally different it’s from fairness, it isn’t so simple as purchase and promote and even worse individuals who do bare choice shopping for on a regular basis as a result of it has “restricted threat limitless reward”. I believe that idea of restricted threat make individuals really feel protected so even when they make a loss they don’t fear about it an excessive amount of and maintain doing senseless choice shopping for and once they verify their P&L assertion that’s when it hits them. And I say this as a predominantly choice purchaser, i just about do choice shopping for 70% of the time.

Additionally as a substitute of SEBI making an attempt to “Save the retailers” and simply make it worse for retailers, they need to deal with large fund managers doing unlawful issues reminiscent of market spoofing. My buddy is doing an internship at one fairly well-known fund and he instructed me how frequent market spoofing is. If sebi actually needs to “save the retailers” deal with this not “let’s enhance margins/taxes in order that these fool poor retailers will probably be saved and must die working their shit job underneath their egoistic boss” yay!

Severely!!! Get a life dude.

Additionally cease commenting on issues you’ve completely no thought about. You don’t have any thought as to the perform of derivatives within the financial system.

I’ve no plan to show you right here. Find out about it, then remark.

By that logic we should always cease giving mortgage to farmers as most of them commit suicide as a result of they’re unable to pay again the loans. Many of the companies fail as properly in long run. That’s the rule of capitalism the system we’ve chosen for this nation.

Is anybody making income besides the tutors or ideas suppliers? If sure, is anybody within the tax bracket of 30% through solely fno earnings?

Bro, I’m not a novice however tried a number of methods on this marketplace for some time. My expertise with equities are constructive however buying and selling is mayhem. It’s not like u r not being profitable however on the finish of month, your ledger is destructive on Realized features. Curious to know when you’ve got been profitable in taming the dragon for greater than a 12 months n pay your payments? That in all probability would inspire me I believe…cuz my CA says in 8 yrs he has seen solely losses for a FY

Even hedging doesn’t work. It protects from a significant capital loss nevertheless it doesn’t assure income. Even when it does, it’s peanuts. The one talent that works in market is predicting path. Hedging helps in haywire actions. I’m unable to tame this dragon. In search of inspiration. However is probably not banned. Reasonably ban these ideas suppliers, they’re those making crores by giving losses to others. And the tutors who by no means made income from precise / actual buying and selling.

Console – Zerodha : Verified P&L from one in all my accounts. I commerce in a number of accounts [trades replicated across them] in order that I don’t get into 30% slab. Buying and selling in a single account would have gotten me into that bracket simply.